Asset pricing and the illiquidity premium request pdf. Momentum and trend following trading strategies for. Illiquidity pricing and the drivers of market liquidity evidence from the swedish stock market philip lindqvist. An academic view on the illiquidity premium and market. The official pdf file is available at foundations and trends in finance. Liquidity and asset pricing munich personal repec archive. The aim of the asset pricing theory is to discover the functional relation. The study is based on amihuds illiq, an illiquidity measured defined as the average ratio of the daily absolute stock excess return to sek volume.
This paper analyzes the amihud 2002 measure of illiquidity and its role in asset pricing. The assumption of frictionless markets is combined with one of the following three concepts. Standard asset pricing standard asset pricing1 is based on the assumption of frictionless or, perfectly liquid markets, where every security can be traded at no cost all of the time, and agents take prices as given. Tabak offers a theoretical model based on the capm, or capital asset pricing model, that allows for a quantification of the illiquidity discount based on objective criteria specific to the asset under consideration. Illiquidity and asset pricing in the chinese stock. He is a past president of the european finance association. The net beta can be decomposed into the standard market beta and three betas representing different forms of. Bm is the booktomarket ratio of equity, computed as the book value for.
We test this hypothesis by incorporating an illiquidity and foreign stock holding factor into the classical capital asset pricing model capm. The financial crisis has underscored the importance of timely and effective measures of systemic risk. The aim of this paper is to examine the role of liquidity in asset. Modern finance theory is based on the idea that financial markets are free of frictions and. Seminars2006seminarsjingchen240106jingchen240106paper. Previous studies mostly adopt single index to analysis. The first chapter investigates the role of the investment horizon in the impact of illiquidity on stock prices. Valuing private equity morten sorensen neng wang jinqiang yang august 7, 20 abstract we develop a dynamic valuation model of private equity pe investments by solving the portfoliochoice problem for a riskaverse investor lp, who invests in a pe fund, managed by a general partner gp. The second contribution of the article relates to corporate finance in that we propose a novel illiquidity augmented tradeoff theory based on trading in secondary debt markets. Moreover, no one has ever studied that from the perspective of information asymmetry. Street, phd, is the mahrt chair in accounting at the university of dayton.
What drives the lownominalprice return premium in chinas. The amortized spread measures the spreads cost over investors holding periods and is approximately equal to the spread times share turnover. A simplified model for portfolio analysis management science. The cost of illiquidity v1 market liquidity discounting. Theory based illiquidity and asset pricing authors chordia, tarun huh, sahnwook subrahmanyam, avanidhar. In business, economics or investment, market liquidity is a markets feature whereby an individual or firm can quickly purchase or sell an asset without causing a drastic change in the asset s price. Avramov, doron, tarun chordia, gergana jostova and alexander philipov, 2009, credit ratings and the crosssection of stock returns, journal of financial markets 12, 469499. Theories of asset pricing suggest that the expected return on an asset is increasing in its risk, because riskaverse investors require a compensation for bearing more risk. This will be of keen interest to risk managers, analysts and asset managers responsible for fixedincome portfolios. Illiquidity discounts 1 illiquidity discount on value 2 assets using higher discount rates 3 illiquidity valued as an option reduce the value of an asset by the illiquidity increases when the not allowed to trade an asset, you the expected cost of trading that market is down which should be lose the option to sell it if the asset over its. Keywords portugal, stock liquidity, asset pricing, commonality. Liquidity, asset prices and financial policy liquidity is an important factor in asset pricing.
Thus, these findings are a challenge for academics and open a theoretical and a practical debate. No lowfrequency based proxies can parallel the priceimpact parameters. Theorybased illiquidity and asset pricing request pdf. Liquidity adjusted capital asset pricing model in an emerging market. The main purposes of this introduction chapter are i to discuss important financial econometrics and statistics which have been used in finance and accounting research and ii to present an overview of 98 chapters which have been included in this handbook. The kyle model does not provide a direct link to illiquidity pricing. The illiquidity premium commonality is not driven by the overall stock market return, as evident from the insignificant coefficient of euro c,t. Theory of debt market illiquidity and leverage cyclicality. However, our findings suggest that the liquidity factor only adds marginal explanatory power to contemporary asset pricing models.
This book demonstrates the important role of liquidity in asset pricing. Thispaperbegins developingonesuch approach based on aggregate liquidityconsiderations. This book presents the theory and evidence on the effect of market liquidity and liquidity risk on asset prices and on overall securities market performance. Inaddition,apersistentnegativeshocktoasecurity sliquidityresultsinlow contemporaneous returns and high predicted future returns. The uncertainty in this book is, rather simplistically, described by proba.
Theorybased illiquidity and asset pricing oxford academic. Private equity operational due diligence wiley online books. Asset pricing theories based on transaction costs, such amihud and mendelson 1986 and constantinides 1986, do not explain the otc illiquidity. That is the netofcost return on an asset must be higher than the netofcost return on the asset which is next to it in terms of lower cost. It is shown first that the effect of illiquidity on asset pricing is clarified by using the turnover version of the amihud measure and including firm size as a separate variable. In the economy as a whole the difference between the amount of cash waiting to be invested and the need to raise cash can be substantial. They concluded that liquidity risk was less relevant than market, size booktomarket factors. In this study, we approach liquidity estimation from a theoretical perspective. Illiquidity means incurring a high transaction cost, which includes a large price impact when trading and facing a long time to unload a large position. Tetlock columbia university abstract compared to listed stocks, overthecounter otc stocks are far less liquid, disclose less information, and exhibit lower institutional holdings. Market liquidity offers a more accurate and authoritative take on liquidity and price discovery. In contrast to standard tradeoff theoretic models, the possibility of endogenous debt relief is factored in. Theorybased illiquidity and asset pricing created date. An important issue in studies that relate illiquidity to asset prices is the measurement of illiquidity.
However, there still exist disputes about the measurement of the degree of information asymmetry. The net beta can be decomposed into the standard market beta and three betas representing different forms of liquidity risk. This is a particular concern for our analysis given the signi. The analysis uses a macro economic theory based approach to examine the impact of capital adequacy regulation on the probabilities of default of us and japanese banks for the period, 20072009 and 19982000, respectively. This worsens the illiquidity problem in the market and reduces prices even further. Illiquidity and pricing biases in the real estate market. Rmreg c,t, and is different from the effects of comovement in stock market returns shown in hardouvelis, malliaropulos, and priestley 2006 and others. A classic example of this literature is amihud and mendelson 1986, who show that expected stock returns are an increasing func. The analysis shows that higher illiquidity and greater liquidity risk reduce securities prices and raise the expected return that investors require as compensation. The value of true liquidity by robin borcherding, michael. This result has generated a large wave of new theory in asset pricing.
The underlying theory of this analysis is the capital market inflation theory, which looks at the system as a. We demonstrate that the negative pricing of credit stocks is driven by the underperformance of stocks which have both high credit risk and which have suffered recent relative underperformance, and that their ongoing poor performance can be explained by a mixture of four limitstoarbitrage factors idiosyncratic risk, turnover, illiquidity and. The illiquidity premium for country c in month t, iprem c,t, is represented by one of the following two measures. For this thesis, liquidity will generally refer to the ease with which an asset can be traded. This result is contradictory to asset pricing models on exogenous transaction costs, which argue that expected return partly represents a liquidity premium to compensate traders for the costs that they bear in illiquid markets. He has also published extensively on asset pricing and. A capmbased approach to calculating illiquidity discounts. Current studies have not reached a unified conclusion.
Illiquidity pricing and the drivers of market liquidity. Illiquid assets may also be hard to sell quickly because of a lack of ready and willing investors or speculators to purchase the asset. An empirical study on listed companys value of cash holdings. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. Pricing of liquidity risks in london stock exchange lutpub. A mathematical theory of financial bubbles springerlink. Price impact as a measure of illiquidity is priced in the crosssection of stock returns. The analysis and appraisal of closely held companies, 1989. Other than direct empirical measurements of illiquidity by the bidask spread, the approach taken in the literature has been to employ empirical arguments and econometric techniques to measure illiquidity. We begin by linking illiquidity and asset pricing in the context of kyle lambdas. The dynamics of discrete bid and ask quotes hasbrouck. The empirical results provide evidence that theorybased estimates of illiquidity are priced in the crosssection of expected stock returns, even after accounting for risk factors, firm characteristics known to influence returns, and other illiquidity proxies prevalent in the literature. The liquidity theory of asset prices explains that an investment transaction often takes place because someone either has cash to invest or needs to raise cash. We establish a strong link between bond illiquidity and bond prices.
The pricing of illiquidity as a characteristic and as risk 153 compensation for the expected cost of illiquidity. We then measure otc firms disclosure of book equity data, which is basic financial. In our liquidityadjusted capital asset pricing model, a securitys re quired return. In terms of model 1, rjk, increases as a function of sj. Abstract theorybased illiquidity and asset pricing. The model implies that a highly liquid asset should command a price. This dissertation studies the pricing of liquidity and illiquid assets. Request pdf theorybased illiquidity and asset pricing many proxies of illiquidity have been used in the literature that relates illiquidity to asset prices. In the process, they recognize a strong common structure in their returns. We obtain a clientele effect where shortterm investors choose not to invest in the least liquid assets. In this section, we provide the theoretical background for our lambda estimation. Asset pricing theories based on transaction costs, such amihud and. Liquidity is about how big the tradeoff is between the speed of the sale and the price it can be sold for.
This paper investigates the shortrun relationship between closedend fund prices and their net asset values. After controlling for known characteristics such as firm size, booktomarket equity and momentum as well as for known sources of risk such as the. The return reversal is another liquidity measure based on price impact which is. This theory, based on the traditional intertemporal capm model, has been used to explain several asset pricing anomalies in recent literaturesee for example campbell and vuolteenaho, 2004. Theories of asset pricing suggest that the amortized cost of the spread is relevant to investors required returns. The cross section of otc stocks june 20 andrew ang, assaf a. Theorybased illiquidity and asset pricing many proxies of illiquidity have been used in the literature that relates illiquidity to asset prices. Full text of handbook of solvency for actuaries and risk.
Faculty publications finance, insurance, and business law. In particular, we document three systematic differences between the shortrun pricing behaviors for stock and bonds funds. Most papers employ the relative bidask spread as a measure of the level liquidity, and study the existence of an illiquidity premium on stock returns. Abstracts and papers alphabetically by presenting authors. A stepbystep guide to develop a flexible comprehensive operational due diligence program for private equity and real estate funds.
Price impact can glean additional information out of highfrequency order flows, doing a better job in capturing. The evidence that liquidity is an important state variable for asset pricing pastor and stambaugh, 2003 and the limited power of the famafrench threefactor model to describe the crosssection of asset returns see, for example, daniel and titman, 1997 motivate me in the second part of this study to develop a liquidityaugmented asset. This paper describes the advantages of using a particular model of the relationships among securities for practical applications of the markowitz portfolio analysis technique. We augment the carhart fourfactor model with a liquidity factor in our asset pricing tests. Theory and evidence from private equity josh lerner and antoinette schoar april 8, 2003 abstract this paper presents a theory, where managers can use the liquidity of securities as a choice variable to screen for \deep pocket investors, those that have a low likelihood of facing a liquidity shock. Introduction to financial econometrics and statistics. We then show how this can be implemented in the conditional lcapm. Using transactions data from 2003 to 2009, we show that the illiquidity in corporate bonds is substantial, significantly greater than what can be explained by bidask spreads. International finance and accounting handbook pdf free download. This paper addresses the issue of whether firms are required to pay an ex ante premium to investors for bearing the risk of interest. The liquidity adjusted capital asset pricing model provides a unified framework for the testing.
These proxies have been motivated from an empirical standpoint. Our evidence is inconsistent with asset pricing theories based on transaction costs, such amihud and mendelson 1986 and constantinides 1986. Asset pricing with liquidity risk june 7, 2004 equities this paper presents a simple theoretical model that helps explain how asset prices are affected by liquidity risk the inability to find buyers or sellers of securities at will and commonality in liquidity. Many proxies of illiquidity have been used in the literature that relates illiquidity to asset prices. The otc illiquidity, size, value, and volatility premiums are largest among stocks. Gross return is an increasing and concave function of the bidask. Theorybased illiquidity and asset pricing by tarun. This does not necessarily mean that investors are better off holding assets. Academics, central banks and international organizations are currently devoting much time and effort to developing tools and models which can be of help in monitoring, identifying and assessing potential threats to the stability of the financial system. For both stocks and bonds, the lower the liquidity of an asset that is, the higher the cost of trading it, the higher the return it is expected to yield. Illiquidity and pricing biases in the real estate market i. The diminishing liquidity premium journal of financial.
This study aims to examine the role of liquidity in asset pricing models as a risk factor, similar to small minus big smb and high minus low hml in the framework of famafrench model and. The pricing of illiquidity as a characteristic and as risk. I believe it to be the first paper to apply the 1 shannon pratt, valuing a business. Iml c,t returnweighted or valueweighted, the return on illiquid stock portfolio minus the return on liquid stock portfolio, and b1 c,t, the famamacbeth regression coefficient associated with the stocklevel illiquidity. The simplest way to think about illiquidity is to consider it the cost of buyers remorse. May, 20 over the last 10 years or so a mathematical theory of bubbles has emerged, in the spirit of a martingale theory based on an absence of arbitrage, as opposed to an equilibrium theory.
In what follows, the theory of liquiditybased asset pricing is surveyed in section 2. Illiquidity and asset pricing in the chinese stock market. Abstract this thesis has a twofold stock liquidity related purpose. Our investigation shows that the relative order of importance of illiquidity risks is the same as concluded by acharya and pedersen 2005. This paper examines the illiquidity of corporate bonds and its asset. Designmethodologyapproach using the available high.
Highlights using intradaily order flows, we estimate a set of priceimpact parameters based on four different models. Otc illiquidity factor has an annual sharpe ratio of 0. Oct 10, 2019 liquidity preference theory is a model that suggests that an investor should demand a higher interest rate or premium on securities with longterm maturities that carry greater risk because, all. However, recent studies have been based on the analysis of commonality in. Finally, the book discusses tools for testing the reasonableness of the key analytics to help build and maintain confidence for using these techniques in daytoday decision making.
Furthermore, they developed a threefactor model which represents the global risk. Using an extensive dataset drawn from the australian equities market, we find that liquidity explains a portion of the common variation in stock returns even after controlling for size, book tomarket and momentum. Theory based illiquidity and asset pricing many proxies of illiquidity have been used in the literature that relates illiquidity to asset prices. Compared to listed stocks, otc stocks are far less liquid, disclose less information, and exh. The risk premium puzzle in real estate proper pricing, evaluation of investment performance, and allocation of real estate in a mixed asset portfolio has proven to be a vexing question. Purpose since illiquidity risk is one of the most important pricing factors of assets, the aim of this paper is to evaluate the suitability of proxies of illiquidity prevalent in the asset pricing literature and their explanatory power in asset pricing tests.